Melee vs Brawl

Dual wrote:

Brawl

I personally liked Melee better because of the gameplay speed.

Are you kidding me, melee is so much slower, and i hate that!

Dual wrote:

Are you kidding me, melee is so much slower, and i hate that!

LOLOLOLOL Do you know what you just said?

Melee


Brawl

LMAO you have realized you compared fox and falco, to link and marth, you dont think that was a bit one-sided.................and i dont mean character spead, i mean roll spead etc.

Dual wrote:

LMAO you have realized you compared fox and falco, to link and marth, you dont think that was a bit one-sided.................and i dont mean character spead, i mean roll spead etc.

First off, Marth is faster than Falco (proven). Second, edited.

Melee is clearly the faster game.

I was really good at melee.

Edit: I split the topic where it got off topic and put it in the debate forum.

melee > brawl. end of story.

I agree, but lets not get too opinionated here. Dual likes brawl better so we have to respect his opinion.

Roy Mustang wrote:

I agree, but lets not get too opinionated here. Dual likes brawl better so we have to respect his opinion.

Good job, Mustang. I knew I could count on you. This man has a point.

Thank you for the respecting of the opinion, but don't you think character reaction speed is a bit slower for melee. Imean I've been plying brawl for a while now, and when i played melee once, I was disgusted with mr game and watches roll speed..........So yea if you like melee, you like melee

Dual wrote:

Thank you for the respecting of the opinion, but don't you think character reaction speed is a bit slower for melee. Imean I've been plying brawl for a while now, and when i played melee once, I was disgusted with mr game and watches roll speed..........So yea if you like melee, you like melee

Only a few character's reaction speed increased as opposed.

Zero wrote:

Dual wrote:

Thank you for the respecting of the opinion, but don't you think character reaction speed is a bit slower for melee. Imean I've been plying brawl for a while now, and when i played melee once, I was disgusted with mr game and watches roll speed..........So yea if you like melee, you like melee

Only a few character's reaction speed increased as opposed.

That's not true, Zero and you know it


The list of characters from Melee to Brawl:

Bowser
Captain Falcon
Donkey Kong
Falco
Fox
Game and Watch
Gannondorf
Ice Climbers
Jigglypuff
Kirby
Link
Luigi
Mario
Marth
Ness
Peach
Pikachu
Samus
Shiek
Yoshi
Zelda


The only difference is the speed of Fox's neutral AAA combo, his Fair and Dair. Other than that he is faster in melee. L cancel and Wavedash also help melee be way faster.

Holy shit, you're right.

Yeah, Ryu just covered everything lulz.

Meh. Hard to say.

Melee for more characters and being a better game for a bunch of human controlled players.

ive only played Brawl

I have to say brawl

I say it really depends on the playing style of the opponents, if you are a really fast player that expects the characters to react instantly then you go for Melee. If you want realistic projectile motion and an endless number of 1-player possibilities your reach for Brawl.

Also, Melee responds faster because there is only one controller option, each button has a set signal. After that signal is received the game runs down the list to see if that's possible then sees what graphic it gets and does it.

Brawl, however, has four(i think...) options that the game has to translate into a signal to the character's code line, then the game determines what action is performed along with the graphic to use, then you get your movement.

That doesn't have anything to do with how fast the gameplay is. Melee had a lot of bugs and they were exploited for cool stuff that also helped the gameplay. Brawl didn't have too many bugs (I dunno if a DAC is one) and perhaps to ensure that they slowed down the gameplay and stuff.

Never heard of anything like that. Is that true Zero?

Well it might be true if it were a retro console like the SNES but the Wii wouldn't have gameplay problems like that. The proof is in Brawl +.

True enough. You would know, right? I mean you did spam the shit out of that game at one point. Both of them.

Melee. They did something with Brawl which I just didn't like.